Nutter Butter Seahawk 12th Man Cookies
Game day spreads should be fun, a little over the top, and full of personality—and these Seahawks 12th Man Nutty Butter cookies check every box. They’re bright, festive, and instantly make your dessert table feel like part of the celebration. Dressed in bold Seahawks blue with pops of bright green, each little cookie feels like a tiny fan cheering right along with you. They’re the kind of treat people smile at before they even take a bite, which is exactly what you want on Super Bowl Sunday.
Add Some Fun To Your Superbowl Party
Tucked in among sliders, wings, and dips, these cookies add a playful, sweet moment to an otherwise savory spread. They’re easy to grab between plays, fun for kids and adults alike, and guaranteed to disappear fast—so don’t be surprised if you find yourself making a second batch before halftime.
Nutter Butter Seahawk 12th Man Football Cookies
Make adorable Seahawks 12th Man cookies using Nutty Butters dipped in blue and green candy melts—an easy, festive game-day treat everyone loves. A crowd-pleasing Super Bowl dessert featuring Seahawks 12th Man Nutter Butter cookies styled in blue and green, displayed on a platter with football-inspired details and party food.
Ingredients
Method
- How to Make Them
- Melt the Milton blue candy melts (or prepare blue icing) according to package directions until smooth. Dip most of each Nutter Butter cookie into the blue coating, letting the excess drip off before placing on parchment paper. This creates the “helmet” base and gives the cookies that bold Seahawks blue look. Let them set briefly in the fridge.
- Once the blue layer is firm, melt the green candy melts and add accent details—think stripes, trim, or a pop of Seahawks green to bring them to life. Next, melt the black candy melts and pipe on simple face-mask lines. Finish by melting the white candy melts and piping a #12 on each cookie for that ultimate fan touch.
- Let everything set completely, then arrange on a platter and prepare for serious game-day compliments.
Notes
💙💚 Gal Pal Notes: 12th Man Nutty Butter Cookies
These cookies are pure nostalgia meets game-day fun—the kind of treat that makes everyone smile before kickoff even happens. We’re taking classic Nutty Butter cookies and dressing them up in Seahawks blue and green to celebrate the 12th Man in the cutest (and easiest) way possible.
This is not a fussy recipe. It’s a put-on-your-favorite-jersey, pour-a-drink, let’s-have-fun situation.
Start with blue candy melts (or blue icing)—this is your star player. That bold Seahawks blue instantly transforms a simple cookie into a mini football fan. When you dip the cookies, don’t worry about perfection. A slightly uneven edge actually makes them look more playful and homemade (which we love).
Once the blue layer sets, bring in the Seahawks green. This is where the cookies really come to life. Add stripes, trim, or accent dips—think just enough green to pop against the blue and scream Seattle pride. You can go minimal or extra here… both are totally on brand.
The black detailing is your “uniform moment.” A few simple lines for the face mask instantly turn these from dipped cookies into actual little football players. No piping bag skills required—just keep it loose and have fun with it.
Now for the best part: the #12. Using white candy melts, add the number front and center so there’s zero confusion who these cookies are cheering for. This tiny detail is what makes them 12th Man cookies, not just football cookies—and Seahawks fans will notice.
Finish with sprinkles if you’re feeling festive. Blue and green sprinkles, a little shimmer, or even edible glitter if you want them to sparkle under the stadium lights (or your kitchen lights). Let everything set, then pile them high on a platter like the MVPs they are.
These are:
- Perfect for Super Bowl Sunday
- Easy enough to make with kids
- Adorable on a dessert table
- Even better as take-home treats for fellow Seahawks fans
